For the second time on American Idol, Brooke White started, stopped and re-started her song.  I don’t remember any other constants re-starting their songs in the past and it can’t be good for votes.

Granted, it is her biggest chance to become a star and it is was re-assuring to her Simon say he would have done the same thing, but this could be the end of the road for Brooke?

Brooke is good, but re-starting a song doesn’t make a very good impression.

What do you think? Does it hurt her, help her or make no difference?